Sunday, March 31, 2013

Lesson 1: London, a large city undergoing major changes




What are the economic, demographic, and environmental changes affecting London?

Refer to pages 82 and 83 of your textbook (HATIER, 2de Classes Européennes History Geography)

Comments on document 1, page 82:
  • Sprawling is tentaculaire (qui s’étalle) in French.
  • Agglomeration means a large urban area (urban core plus suburbs and outer suburbs).
  • It is a world city (an “anglo-saxon” city, i.e. where English is spoken).
  • In terms of population size, it is only the 25th largest in the world (biggest in Europe), with about 15 million people (for Greater London).
  • It was the largest urban area in the world (with the largest port) in the 19th century and up to the 1930s.
  • The City in London is the second financial centre in the world (after New York).
  • Document 1 shows London on a smaller scale than the document 2 map; it gives information on London in its wider context.
  • London is at the centre of a spider-web-like communication network (road and rail) which links the capital to the South-East, the rest of the UK, and indeed the rest of the world (via the Channel tunnel rail link).
  • Every day, nearly 4 million people commute from the suburbs to go to work in central London.
  • Central London + suburbs + outer suburbs = Greater London (32 Boroughs spread over 1,500km²).
  • The Green Belt (= 5,000km²) around London was decided as part of the Greater London Plan in 1944; it limits the amount of housing and urban sprawl, and preserves the countryside.
  • The Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty also preserve the countryside (they were created in 1949 as part of the National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act).
  • New Towns like Stevenage and Harlow were built to reduce the urban pressure of the centre of the capital.

Comments on document 2, page 82:
  • Urban mutations means changes over time of a town or city.
  • There has been a settlement in this area from well before the Romans.
  • Llyn-Din (meaning the fort near the lake) is the Celtic name for what the Romans came to call Londinium.
  • London was built next to a ford crossing on the Thames, on a relatively high sandy area of the surrounding marshland.
  • The City is the oldest part of London, built around a port and a bridge over the river; London was a merchant city.
  • William the Conqueror built the Tower of London in 1078 to protect the city.
  • The City is today a Central Business District (the eldest of two CBDs) with the Bank of England and the Stock Exchange.
  • Downstream from the City, docks were built for large merchant ships between the 1850s and the 1920s during the height of the British Empire, when Great Britain traded all over the world.
  • The dock basins could be closed so the ships would not keel over at low tide.
  • Because of the extensive damage to the docks during the Blitz and the increase in size of merchant ships, the London docks were gradually abandoned.
  • The Docklands area around Canary Wharf was redeveloped in the 1980s and 1990s into a second CBD (with offices, luxury residencesand an airport).
  • Upstream from the City is Westminster, the political centre of London with the Houses of Parliament and Westminster Abbey (where the crowning ceremonies take place).

Answers to the questions on documents 1 and 2:

1) Introduce the maps.

Document 1 map has a smaller scale than document 2 map; it shows London in its wider context.
Note the Green Belt, Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty and New Towns which are means to limit London’s urban sprawl.
The dense motorway network plus two international airports show that London is a major transport HUB.
Document is a map that shows detail of the different areas and their functions of the centre of London.
The dense road and rail routes are indicated (not the underground Tube though).
The smaller map of the original site of London shows us how much London has spread since medieval times!

2) What relations exist between a city and its environment? What are the policies that shape the expansion of a city?

The way a town develops obviously evolves according to its environment; the Thames is what structures the layout of London: buildings spread out along the north and south banks of the river. The Thames was an essential transport route for merchandise (and people) up until the first half of the 20th century.
Urban planning also affects how a city grows: for example, in London, the activity and type of population of the docklands area has changed because of a redevelopment initiative; the railway lines to the outer suburbs and New Towns have created residential areas outside of London to relieve urban pressure; the creation of the Green Belt has discouraged urban sprawl.

3) List the advantages of London’s original site.

The original site had the advantage of: a ford crossing over the Thames (there were therefore two means of transport at this crossing point: road and river); dry ground above the surrounding marshland; water; a reasonable distance to the sea.

4) Describe the different districts and their functions (make use of Google Earth too!).

EAST END: residential, CBD
CITY: historic centre, business district
WEST END: shopping and leisure
WESTMINSTER: political centre
SOUTH: shopping and leisure, residential
NORTH; residential

Description of document 3, page 83:
  • In the foreground, on the right, is Southwark (note the new City Hall, the headquarters of the Greater London Authority).
  • Tower Bridge over the Thames joins the south bank to the north bank of the river.
  • In the foreground on the left (north bank) is the Tower of London (the City is to the left, out of the picture).
  • Moving downriver, one can see the renovated Saint Katharine’s Docks, inner city residential areas (including council estates), then the new Docklands CBD (recognisable by the tall prestigious buildings).

Comments on documents 4 and 5, page 83:
  • Document 4 is an extract from an Australian newspaper (dated 2003), giving an international perspective.
  • Document 5 is an extract of an article that appeared in The Economist, a British magazine, in 2004.
  • Both documents describe London’s efforts to limit traffic congestion, namely a toll fee on cars entering the centre of London.
  • The toll fee was unpopular (because very expensive), but it has proved successful (there has been a 30% drop in car traffic).
  • Pollution levels have also declined.

Monday, March 25, 2013

"Koyaanisqatsi" means, in the Hopi language, a (crazy) state of life that calls for another way of living

Click HERE to watch the video!
  1. Describe each image of the film, plus the accompanying sounds and music.
  2. Write down your thoughts, feelings, memories as you watch the film.
  3. List the different sections of the film.
  4. Choose a particular image from the documentary, describe it in detail, and explain what its significance is for you.
  5. What is this film "about" (how does the title relate to the contents of the documentary)?
  6. Is it a good movie, according to you (what is good/bad about it)?
  7. What have others said about it?

Friday, March 8, 2013

School meals...



Questions/activities:
  1. Do YOUR school meals resemble most the meal shown in the upper photo or the lower one!?
  2. What is your ideal school meal (warning: you will have to eat that ideal meal for the rest of your school days!)?
  3. Do a quick survey among your friends on what they like/dislike about the experience of eating at school (what are their criteria for choosing their school meal)?
  4. Would you prefer to eat a packed lunch (would you prepare it, and what would you include in it)?
  5. Do you think we should learn at school how to eat better?

Friday, March 1, 2013

There is enough in the world for everyone's need; there is not enough for everyone's greed (Gandhi)


Questions/to do:
  1. Describe what happens in the video extract on overconsumption.
  2. What is the purpose of this video do you think (how does the film maker put over his message)?
  3. What is your reaction to what the video shows?
  4. What is "overconsumption"?
  5. How much do you agree with what Gandhi said?

Social and spatial disparity in Hong Kong...



Questions on the Huffington Post article (click on above link!):
  1. In what type of housing do the wealthiest inhabitants live?
  2. How many people live in “inadequate housing”?
  3. How big are the metal cages?
  4. Why do people live in “coffin apartments”, metal cages, cubicle apartments, or rooftop shacks?
  5. How are the authorities hoping to tackle the problem?
  6. Why is the city’s leader unpopular?
  7. How many people live in public rental flats?
  8. How many people live at or below the poverty line?
  9. Do the poor have much hope of getting a decent home?
  10. Is the housing shortage threatening social stability?

Answers to the above questions:
  1. They live in mansions and luxury apartments (there are many in Victoria Peak).
  2. About 100,000 (in working class areas like Sham Shui Po district, and Jordan area in Yau Tsim Mong district, cf. Google Earth map of Hong Kong!).
  3. 1,5m². They are cramped, unsafe, and dirty (there are bed bugs).
  4. Because of the “skyrocketing housing prices” the poorest can only afford this type of accommodation.
  5. The authorities will “boost supply of public housing”.
  6. Because people think he is not doing enough to solve the housing crisis (i.e. not building enough cheap housing quickly).
  7. About 1/3 of Hong Kong’s 7,1 million inhabitants.
  8. About 1,19 million (and the number is rising fast).
  9. No, as decent private flats are too expensive, and there is a long wait (at least four years) for a public rental flat.
  10. Yes, the overcrowding and the insalubrious environment lead to social unrest. The social and spatial divide in Hong Kong is very marked; rich people live in luxury homes in the most pleasant parts of the city, whilst the poor are crowded into the poor areas. The population pressure (i.e. too many people for the amount of available space) means that there is a high demand for living space, the cost of which increases with the rising demand. Even middle class people are finding it more and more difficult to rent or buy a decent home. Hong Kong is a divided city because of population pressure, but also because the economic and social system of Hong Kong favours the wealthy, and because the local authorities are inefficient.



 Shocking disparity in HK (photos)

 Human battery hens... (photos)


Rooftop homes in Sham Shui Po district (photos)



Questions on the following video (click on link!): VIDEO: The GINI is out of the bottle!
  1. What is worse than it has been for the last three decades?
  2. What does the Gini coefficient measure?
  3. What is the government arguing?
  4. By how much did the income of Hong Kong’s poorest 10% drop over the period 2006-2009 (in HK$)?
  5. By how much did the income of Hong Kong’s wealthiest 10% increase in the period 2006-2009 (in HK$)?
  6. When was the minimum wage introduced?
  7. What “should be our major target” in solving poverty according to Law Chi-kwang?
  8. Why, according to Sze Lai-shan, was the previous Commission on Poverty inefficient?
Answers to the above questions on the video:
  1. It is the gap in income between Hong Kong’s wealthiest and poorest inhabitants.
  2. It measures income inequality.
  3. That poverty is “not as bad as it looks”!
  4. It has decreased by 180$ per annum on average (which does not seem much, but the cost of living has increased).
  5. It has increased on average by more than 19,000$.
  6. It was introduced in 2011.
  7. The lower income elderly households should be helped most.
  8. It had little power to implement change or have public spending increased.

http://feedinghk.org/hunger-stats/


More documents on Hong Kong to study (click on the links below):



Questions (to answer, you will need to have studied ALL the links listed above!):
  1. In what ways is Hong Kong a divided society?
  2. What might be the long-term result of these inequalities?
  3. How similar is your town to Hong Kong as regards social and spatial divisions?